Thoughts Post-Toast (or, Why You Should Not Assume Your Publishing Contract Doesn’t Apply to You)

Posted by Victoria Strauss for Writer Beware

As I've followed the discussion (for instance, here, here, and here) over the past couple of days about literary ezine The Toast's demand that writers surrender copyright (the demand was first reported by me, and The Toast has since announced that it's eliminating the demand from its contracts), I've been struck by the number of comments from writers who seem to think that a bad contract clause is not so very awful if (pick one) the publication is great; the people who run it are great; the bad contract clause is not always enforced. (See especially the comments thread on The Toast's post about the controversy.)

That's all very well. But (and I'm speaking generally here, not in particular about The Toast) this is exactly how writers get screwed: by making assumptions about a publisher's intentions, by letting their emotions overrule their business sense, and by forgetting that, in the author-publisher relationship, the publishing contract is the bottom line.

Here are some suggestions for changing those damaging ways of thinking.

  • Don't assume that every single word of your contract won't apply to you at some point. You may think "Oh, that will never happen" (for instance, the publisher's right to refuse to publish your manuscript if it thinks that changes in the market may reduce your sales). Or the publisher may tell you "We never do that" (for instance, edit at will without consulting you). But if your contract says it can happen, it may well happen--and if it does happen, can you live with it? That's the question you need to ask yourself when evaluating a contract.
  • Don't mistake "nice" or "responsive" or "professional" or even "crazy about my work" for "author-friendly." Remember, the lovely, enthusiastic editors you deal with when you submit your work probably didn't create the contract (they may not even be fully aware of its provisions). It's a sad truth of the industry that wonderful publishers can have shitty contracts. Don't let your warm fuzzy feelings push aside your business sense.
  • Don't make assumptions about what contract language means. If you don't understand the meaning of a clause, or aren't sure about its implications, don't guess. Get advice from someone qualified to provide it.
  • Don't rely on your publisher's assurance that objectionable contract language won't be enforced. Your publisher may be telling the truth--at least, up to the point that they give you the assurance. But even if they aren't just trying to get you to shut up and sign, circumstances may alter (what if management changes? What if the publisher sells itself?) and internal policies may shift. Promises that contradict contract language offer you absolutely no protection or guarantees (especially if your contract contains a clause like this one). Never forget that by signing a contract, you are giving your publisher the full legal right to enforce it.
  • Don't accept your publisher's claim that contract language means something different from what you think it means. This is a response you may receive if you attempt to negotiate changes, or bring a troublesome clause to your publisher's attention. Your publisher may be correct: the misinterpretation may be yours. But your publisher may also be unscrupulous or ignorant (many small presses don't properly understand their own contract language). If your publisher's explanation doesn't sound right, don't just take their word for it. Get a second opinion.
  • Don't let your publisher convince you that asking questions is a bad thing. Dodgy or incompetent publishers don't like pro-active authors, and may try to blow them off by claiming that asking questions is unprofessional, or ungrateful, or something similarly bogus. But asking questions is your right. Walk away from a publisher that won't let you exercise it.

No contract is perfect. You should always be able to do at least some negotiation--but even under the most favorable circumstances, you'll probably be giving something up. You may even decide to swallow an objectionable clause because of a great opportunity (I don't know of any writer, including me, who hasn't made this decision on occasion). But if you do decide to sign a contract with unfavorable language, do so in full understanding of the possible consequences. Not in ignorance, or assumption, or fear of annoying the publisher by being too inquisitive.

I'll close with an excellent tweet from author and editor Jane Friedman (if you aren't following her, you should be):

Words to live by.

Rights Grab: Transferring Copyright

Posted by Victoria Strauss for Writer BewareThe Toast is an online literary magazine that publishes stories, articles, artwork, reviews, and more. Launched in mid-2013, it’s associated with some respected names and apparently draws a sizeable audience…. [...]

Continue reading Rights Grab: Transferring Copyright

Alert: Questionable Terms of Use in HBO's Game of Thrones Compendium

Posted by Victoria Strauss for Writer BewareIf you’re an artist and a Game of Thrones fan, you may have heard that HBO is inviting contributions to “the ultimate compendium to Game of Thrones.”What exactly is the Compendium? According to the FAQ:The Ga… [...]

Continue reading Alert: Questionable Terms of Use in HBO’s Game of Thrones Compendium

Don’t Do This: Wrong Ways to Try and Escape Your Deadbeat Publisher

Posted by Victoria Strauss for Writer BewareThe other day, I received this email:Dear Writer Beware, A couple of years ago, I published my mystery novel with [insert name of well-known deadbeat publisher here]. My contract won’t expire for several mor… [...]

Continue reading Don’t Do This: Wrong Ways to Try and Escape Your Deadbeat Publisher

MeGustaEscribir: Author Solutions Inc. Expands Into Spain

Posted by Victoria Strauss for Writer BewareToday I’m highlighting a post by author and self-publishing expert David Gaughran. Like Writer Beware, David has been following Author Solutions Inc. closely over the past few years, and has written a number … [...]

Continue reading MeGustaEscribir: Author Solutions Inc. Expands Into Spain

Scam Warnings For Freelancers

Posted by Victoria Strauss for Writer BewareIdentity Theft This week, freelance writer Heather Boerner (who has published with such well-known venues as The Atlantic and The Washington Post) alerted me to her experience with a scammer.Heather discovere… [...]

Continue reading Scam Warnings For Freelancers

Alert: Cookbook Marketing Agency

Posted by Victoria Strauss for Writer BewareAre you thinking of creating your own cookbook–or have you already created one? Good news: an apparently new venture called Cookbook Marketing Agency is here to help.Cookbook Marketing Agency (CMA) is a glob… [...]

Continue reading Alert: Cookbook Marketing Agency

Garden, Mid-November 2014: The Colors of Fall

Usually the garden is destroyed by frost by this time, but we’ve had an unusually long, slow fall, so there’s still quite a lot of lovely color to be seen, especially with my gorgeous Japanese maples. We’re expecting hard frosts over the next few days, though, so this is really the last gasp before everything goes to sleep for another year.

#gallery-1 { margin: auto; } #gallery-1 .gallery-item { float: left; margin-top: 10px; text-align: center; width: 33%; } #gallery-1 img { border: 2px solid #cfcfcf; } #gallery-1 .gallery-caption { margin-left: 0; }

Solicitation Alert: LitFire Publishing

Posted by Victoria Strauss for Writer BewareA few weeks ago, I began hearing from writers who’d been solicited, out of the blue, by a company called LitFire Publishing. In some cases by phone, in others by email, a LitFire “consultant” claimed to have … [...]

Continue reading Solicitation Alert: LitFire Publishing

Kindle Scout: The Pros and Cons of Amazon's New Crowdsourced Publishing Program

Posted by Victoria Strauss for Writer BewareYesterday, Amazon’s brand-new crowdsourced publishing program, Kindle Scout, opened for voting by the public.The concept is pretty simple:Kindle Scout is reader-powered publishing for new, never-before-publis… [...]

Continue reading Kindle Scout: The Pros and Cons of Amazon’s New Crowdsourced Publishing Program